News Summary
Moses Young III has been sentenced to eight years in prison for the voluntary manslaughter of Anthony Keith Chapman, who was shot during a domestic dispute. The incident occurred in Hilton Head while Chapman was visiting. Young, facing a murder charge initially, was convicted after prosecutors argued his actions did not constitute self-defense. This case sheds light on the complexities of domestic violence and self-defense laws.
Hilton Head Island — Moses Young III, a 35-year-old man, has been sentenced to eight years in prison for the voluntary manslaughter of Anthony Keith Chapman, 37, who was fatally shot during a domestic dispute on March 1, 2024. The incident occurred at the home of Young’s sister in Hilton Head, South Carolina, while Chapman was visiting from Chicago.
Young was convicted of voluntary manslaughter and felony gun possession, receiving a partially suspended sentence that allows for two years of probation following his prison term. Due to time already served, Young will spend just under seven years in prison if he is not released early. He had initially faced a murder charge, which carried a minimum sentence of 30 years and the possibility of the death penalty.
According to court documents, the shooting took place around 3 a.m. during a heated argument between Chapman and Young’s sister. Young allegedly fired the pistol because he believed Chapman was physically attacking his sister. However, prosecutors asserted that Young’s actions did not qualify as self-defense under the law, as Chapman was unarmed at the time.
Investigators reported that Young moved Chapman’s body outside the residence and attempted to mislead law enforcement about the circumstances of the shooting. Furthermore, a surveillance camera captured audio of the confrontation, but the video footage was blocked, limiting evidence available to the court. Witnesses stated that both Young and Chapman had been drinking prior to the incident, raising questions about their state of mind.
Law enforcement found the .40-caliber Taurus pistol used in the shooting to be stolen from Savannah, complicating Young’s defense case. Following the shooting, Young was screened at Beaufort Memorial Hospital before being taken into custody on charges of murder. He expressed remorse during transport by police, repeatedly apologizing for the incident.
Young’s sister reported that Chapman had been “grabbing her by the hair and the face” during the altercation, providing a context for Young’s reaction. Although she did not sustain any injuries, she later described Young’s actions as “unnecessary,” contributing to the complexity of the case presented in court.
Young’s defense attorney highlighted the plea deal as a reflection of Young’s intention to protect his sister, while prosecutors characterized the case as an example of “imperfect self-defense.” They stressed that there were other options available for resolving the situation without resorting to violence.
Young has a prior criminal record that includes convictions for carrying a pistol illegally and various drug offenses, adding to the scrutiny surrounding his actions on the night of the shooting. After his conviction, Young was booked at the Kirkland Reception and Evaluation Center in Columbia, South Carolina, where he will begin serving his sentence.
This case highlights the tragic repercussions of domestic disputes and raises broader questions about self-defense laws and the responsibilities associated with gun ownership. The tension between protecting loved ones and responding appropriately to potential threats continues to be a complex issue in the legal system.
Deeper Dive: News & Info About This Topic
HERE Resources
Tragic Family Incident Leads to Sentencing in Burton
Additional Resources
- ABC News 4
- Wikipedia: Voluntary Manslaughter
- Live 5 News
- Google Search: Hilton Head Island crime
- Post and Courier
- Encyclopedia Britannica: Self-Defense
- Island Packet
- Google News: Domestic Disputes in South Carolina
